A model of local and global reciprocity

2026-06-11T17:59:49Z

We often decide how to treat friends based on observations of their past behavior, whereas actions toward strangers are typically guided by their public reputations. These two kinds of information underlie two classical mechanisms for the evolution of cooperation$\unicode{x2014}$direct and indirect reciprocity$\unicode{x2014}$which have largely been studied in isolation. They are not interchangeable: we can recall the past actions of only a small circle of close contacts, whereas for the far larger pool of strangers we must rely on public reputations. Here we develop a mathematical framework built on this distinction. Each individual engages in direct reciprocity in local games within a finite neighborhood of friends, whose actions they observe directly, and in indirect reciprocity in global games with a large population of strangers, known only by reputation. Separating local and global interactions allows us to address two questions. First, can cooperation persist under a cognitively simple norm of judgment? We show that combining direct and indirect reciprocity resolves the scoring dilemma: conditional cooperators resist invasion by both unconditional cooperators and unconditional defectors, where indirect reciprocity alone would fail. Second, how should one treat a friend whose past behavior conflicts with their public reputation? We find that the strategies that maximize cooperation are forgiving$\unicode{x2014}$overlooking whichever piece of information is unfavorable$\unicode{x2014}$and that these forgiving strategies can often remain robust to invasion. By distinguishing between local and global scales of interaction and integrating information across them, our framework offers a more cognitively realistic account of how reciprocity sustains cooperation.

A kernel for the maximum agreement forest problem on multiple binary phylogenetic trees

2026-06-11T17:47:18Z

The maximum agreement forest (MAF) problem in phylogenetics takes as input a set t >= 2 of binary phylogenetic trees T on the same set of taxa X. It asks for a partition of X into the smallest number of blocks such that the subtrees induced by these blocks are disjoint and have common topology across all the trees in T. We produce a modified version of the well-known chain reduction rule in order to prove that after exhaustive application of reduction rules each tree has O( t * r * k ) leaves, where k is the natural parameter (the number of blocks) and r=min{max{k,3},t+1}}. We prove this bound for both the unrooted and rooted version of the problem, and demonstrate that the bound r, the length to which common chains are truncated, is tight. Our results constitute the first kernels for MAF in the t>2 regime.

A likelihood-based framework for simultaneously learning both noise and growth dynamics using biologically-informed neural networks

2026-06-11T15:29:14Z

In recent years, neural ordinary differential equation frameworks such as Biologically-Informed Neural Networks (BINNs) have shown promise for learning mechanistic laws from sparse data. However, most existing approaches implicitly assume homoscedastic Gaussian noise, and therefore do not account for potentially meaningful structure in biological variability. Here, we present an extension to the existing BINNs framework that includes a learnable noise model, allowing discovery of the noise model directly from data. Using population growth as an example, we demonstrate that the framework accurately recovers the underlying noise structure and improves predictions of the underlying growth laws compared to existing approaches. As such, this work establishes a general likelihood-based framework for jointly learning dynamics and heteroscedastic noise within mechanistic neural network approaches.

The evolutionary advantage of replacers in the Moran process

2026-06-11T13:53:52Z

Evolution occurs in populations of reproducing individuals. In stochastic descriptions of evolutionary dynamics, such as the Moran process, individuals are chosen randomly for birth and for death. If the same type is chosen for both steps, then the reproductive event is wasted, because the composition of the population remains unchanged. Here we introduce a new phenotype, which we call a replacer. Replacers are efficient competitors. When a replacer is chosen for reproduction, the offspring will always replace an individual of another type (if available). We determine the selective advantage of replacers in well-mixed populations and on one-dimensional lattices. We find that being a replacer substantially boosts the fixation probability of neutral and deleterious mutants. In particular, fixation probability of a single neutral replacer who invades a well-mixed population of size $N$ is of the order of $1/\sqrt N$ rather than the standard $1/N$. Even more importantly, replacers are much better protected against invasions once they have reached fixation. Therefore, replacers dominate the mutation selection equilibrium even if the phenotype of being a replacer comes at a substantial cost: curiously, for large population size and small mutation rate the relative reproductive rate of a successful replacer can be as low as $1/e$.

A structural causal framework for interventions on evolutionary accumulation models

2026-06-10T18:52:53Z

Evolutionary accumulation models (EvAMs), also known as cancer progression models (CPMs), infer dependencies in the order of accumulation of mutations during tumor progression from cross-sectional data. It has been suggested that EvAMs could be used to identify therapeutic targets, but there is no procedure in the literature for how to extract predictions under intervention from these models. A simple approach of conditioning on the absence of a mutation gives incorrect predictions. We address this gap by formalizing what ``intervene'' means for all currently available EvAM methods (OT, OncoBN, CBN, H-ESBCN, MHN, HyperHMM, HyperTraPS), using Pearl's do operator and conditional interventions. For each model, we show how to implement the intervention (in most cases as specific parameter modifications), identify equivalent implementation procedures, and analyze whether the modularity assumption -- required for the intervention to be well-defined -- is justified. Drawing on individual-level causal DAGs that make fitness an explicit variable, we distinguish two types of intervention (killing and inactivating) that are conflated in standard EvAM representations. Since the goal is to prioritize intervention candidates, we recast the problem as one of ranking: we define three intervention objectives and provide a protocol for evaluating how well EvAMs rank targets. Our framework is not specific to cancer or EvAMs; it applies wherever fitted computational models can be interpreted as structural causal models. Code available from https://github.com/rdiaz02/scm-interv-evams.

SCAR dynamics of adolescent substance use: peer influence, dropout, and bifurcation structure in a school-based model

2026-06-10T18:15:20Z

We develop a four-compartment susceptible--casual--addicted--resistant (SCAR) model for adolescent substance use in a high-school setting. The model divides students into susceptible non-users, casual or experimental users, students with sustained or substance-use-disorder (SUD)-level involvement, and resistant students in protective anti-use environments. It includes peer-driven initiation, escalation from casual to problematic use, protective peer influence, school disengagement, and partial re-entry after rehabilitation. Qualitative analysis and bifurcation diagrams show three main results. First, the return parameter $φ$ separates two regimes: when $φ=1$, the total population is conserved and interior equilibria may exist; when $φ<1$, problematic use causes net school-population loss, so positive scaled equilibria may not represent true endemic equilibria. Second, initiation and escalation are governed by distinct thresholds, meaning first use and progression to problematic use are dynamically different. Third, the model can exhibit multistability, including bistability between a substance-free state and a stable high-use state, so long-term outcomes may depend on initial conditions. These findings suggest that effective school policy should combine universal prevention, early intervention for casual users, targeted support for students at risk of problematic use, recovery-supportive environments, and strong school re-engagement pathways.

Towards a less spherical cow: Species differences dilute the stabilizing effect of higher-order interactions

2026-06-10T12:08:43Z

Ecological models traditionally explain stability and coexistence through pairwise interactions among species. However, interactions can also involve groups of three or more species, higher-order interactions, which recent theory suggests can stabilize communities. Yet, the conditions under which higher-order interactions are sufficient to stabilize coexistence in communities where pairwise and higher-order interactions occur simultaneously remain unknown. This work addresses this gap by analyzing a model of competitive communities that incorporates a proportion of pairwise and higher-order interactions. Using empirical data, numerical simulations, and analytical methods, we show that higher-order interactions alone cannot guarantee coexistence. We find that, while a small fraction of higher-order interactions can stabilize dynamics in communities of identical species, this effect weakens under more realistic conditions, such as variability in birth and mortality rates or explicit interaction structures. Our results challenge the prevailing view of higher-order interactions as a universal stabilizing mechanism, providing quantitative evidence of the joint importance of both pairwise and higher-order interactions, together with network structure and species parameters, for understanding ecological stability.

Multiple Poisson-Dirichlet diffusions on generalized Kingman simplices

2026-06-10T06:19:41Z

We construct a new class of infinite-dimensional diffusions with values in a generalized Kingman simplex with finitely many marks. The model describes the temporal evolution of the relative frequencies of infinitely many types that are labeled by a finite number $H$ of marks, but unlabeled within each mark. We first establish a blockwise skew-product representation for a finite-type Wright-Fisher diffusion, extending the aggregation-renormalization self-similarity property of Dirichlet laws. The decomposition separates an $H$-dimensional Wright-Fisher diffusion governing the evolving random mark masses, from $H$ Wright-Fisher diffusions, each run on its own random clock, which describe the evolution of the relative frequencies within each mark. After ranking the within-mark frequencies in decreasing order, we identify the distributional limit as the number of types per mark tends to infinity and we derive an explicit form of its infinitesimal generator on a suitable domain. The limiting diffusion admits the multiple Poisson-Dirichlet distribution as a stationary distribution; it recovers the infinitely-many-neutral-alleles diffusion when all types share the same mark and yields a diffusion on the Thoma simplex when there are two marks.

Continuous biome representations from Earth observation embeddings

2026-06-09T23:14:00Z

Biotic communities vary continuously across space, yet biome maps impose categorical boundaries that compress this variation, particularly at ecotones where transitional communities are ecologically distinct. Could Earth observation (EO) foundation models, which encode spectral, spatial, and temporal information with dense embeddings, convert discrete biome maps into continuous representations that better capture ecological variation? Here, we fit a linear classifier on Clay v1.5 satellite image embeddings to predict biome labels from a categorical map. The softmax output yields a continuous probability vector whose dimensions correspond to named biome classes. We evaluate this approach using six Brazilian biomes, 1.3 million embeddings, and 10,015 withheld forest inventory plots spanning 4,672 plant species. The continuous biome representation outperforms discrete biome labels for predicting species occurrence (mean per-species AUC 0.618 vs. 0.570 across 10 spatial cross-validation folds). Decomposing this gain shows that continuity in the graded probability output, rather than label reassignment, accounts for the improvement; the pattern holds across all distances from biome boundaries. The raw 1024-dimensional embedding remains the strongest predictor we tested (mean AUC 0.646 vs. 0.618), but the continuous representation recovers most of the embedding's gain over discrete labels. This simple approach provides a probabilistic replacement for categorical map labels, preserving their meaning while encoding graded variation that discrete maps suppress.

Bayesian Rate Inference for Sequence Motif Dynamics in Systems of Reactive Nucleic Acids

2026-06-09T18:43:22Z

The RNA world hypothesis suggests a pathway of how life emerged on early earth. It assumes that life started with RNA based systems, capable of storing, transmitting and replicating information, envisioning that monomers and short RNA oligomers interact to form longer strands, eventually becoming catalytically active ribozymes. Key reactions in RNA pools are hybridization, dehybridization, templated ligation, and cleavage. Those reactions depend on many environmental parameters and the wide range of possible configurations among interacting strands. In order to scan such high dimensional parameter spaces, efficient descriptions are needed. Motif rate equations project complex strand reactor dynamics onto sequence motif space. Here we present a Bayesian inference framework to infer their parameters from ligation count data produced by strand reactor simulations. This provides a framework to match the simpler motif rate equations to more complex simulations. Additionally, it is a step towards inferring reaction rate constants directly from experimental data, including rigorous uncertainty estimation. This could be an essential procedure to connect theory and experiment, and deepen our understanding of the essential features necessary for life to emerge.

The $B_2$ index of galled trees

2026-06-09T13:38:27Z

In recent years, there has been an effort to extend the classical notion of phylogenetic balance, originally defined in the context of trees, to networks. One of the most natural ways to do this is with the so-called $B_2$ index. In this paper, we study the $B_2$ index for a prominent class of phylogenetic networks: galled trees. We show that the $B_2$ index of a uniform leaf-labeled galled tree converges in distribution as the network becomes large. We characterize the corresponding limiting distribution, and provide a way to compute its moments. This is the first time that a balance index has been studied to this level of detail for a random phylogenetic network. One specificity of this work is that we use two different and independent approaches, each with its advantages: analytic combinatorics, and local limits. The analytic combinatorics approach is more direct, as it relies on standard tools; but it involves slightly more complex calculations. Because it has not previously been used to study such questions, the local limit approach requires developing an extensive framework beforehand; however, this framework is interesting in itself and can be used to tackle other similar problems.

Chaos and stability in the marine trophic network: the importance of interactions over complexity

2026-06-09T12:54:35Z

Understanding the dynamics of real world complex networks is crucial for assessing their predictability, resilience, and improving ecosystem management, especially in the context of climate change. The relationship between stability and complexity in ecological networks is still debated in the literature. In this modeling study, we investigate whether a complex marine trophic network, characterized by multiple trophic interactions and environmental constraints, exhibits predominantly stable, periodic or chaotic dynamics. We incorporate the microbial loop into a trophic network model, which includes one to three primary producers, one or two consumers, and up to three trophic levels of predators. The microbial loop is a key process in which bacteria recycle detritus from higher trophic levels into nutrients available for the growth of primary producers, ensuring mass conservation within the system. We perform numerical simulations to investigate the dynamic behavior of the network, exploring several configurations by turning off predator prey links between species and varying the high dimensional parameter space. Our results show that (i) longer trophic chains and (ii) a higher number of consumers increase system chaoticity, whereas (iii) omnivorous interactions promote stability. Notably, many of the configurations exhibit high percentages of chaotic behavior. Feedback loop analysis suggests that the balance between negative and positive interactions plays a key role in the convergence of the system toward a steady state. This study shows that interactions and feedback, rather than complexity, are key drivers of stability, pointing to the absence of a clear stability complexity relationship and instead highlighting a stability interaction dependence. Chaotic dynamics may also play an important role, with potential implications for predictability and ecosystem management.

A systematic review of COVID-19 epidemic models with endogenous human behaviour. What's next?

2026-06-09T12:46:38Z

Human behaviour and epidemic dynamics are intertwined, yet accounting for this feedback remains one of the key challenges of epidemiological modelling. The COVID-19 pandemic was an opportunity to overcome the traditional limitations of the field, raising expectations that data-informed endogenous approaches to behaviour modelling would advance substantially. To quantify the progresses made, we conducted a systematic review of SARS-CoV-2 transmission models endogenously including human behaviour in response to epidemic dynamics. The COVID-19 pandemic saw great strides in terms of the expanded use of empirical data in epi-behavioural modelling. However, it also showed shortcomings with respect to limited use of behavioural empirical data, lack of innovation in model structure, and limited engagement with other disciplines and decision-makers. Overall, our results suggest that identifying priorities in model design and behavioural data, building an adequate data collection infrastructure, leveraging on AI advancements, and fostering interdisciplinarity are strategies of utmost importance for pandemic preparedness.

Modeling pest dynamics in trap cropping to improve yield: the effects of attraction, retention, and land allocation

2026-06-09T09:05:47Z

Trap crops reduce damage to a cash (main) crop by attracting pests away from it. Yet this protection is weakened when pests disperse back into the cash crop. In this paper, we focus on the importance of preventing this backflow, showing that effective trap cropping depends jointly on how strongly pests are attracted to trap plants and how rarely they leave them. Together with the proportion of the field devoted to trap plants, these processes determine both the efficacy and feasibility of trap cropping at commercial scales. We formalise this relationship using a simple yield-maximisation framework, in which growers weigh pest suppression benefits against the land sacrificed to trap plants. The model shows that when dispersal from trap plants equals that from the cash crop, optimal trap coverage can exceed 20 to 30 percent of the landscape, levels rarely acceptable to growers. However, reducing pest dispersal off trap plants to just one-quarter of cash crop dispersal lowers the optimal required trap area to approximately 5 percent, transforming trap cropping from impractical to feasible. Understanding these relationships can guide trap-cropping design, from plant choice to targeted interventions that reduce pest movement, to minimise damage, maximise yield, and make trap cropping a reliable component of sustainable pest management.

Stabilizing Role of Uninformed Participants in Collective Decision Making

2026-06-09T01:24:38Z

For groups without strict hierarchy, collective decisions often emerge through compromise. We develop a second-order network model of collective decision-making using a dissipative Hamiltonian formulation, in which informed agents introduce preferred directions while uninformed participants contribute only direction-free dissipation. We show that under low conflict, the model admits a locally unique, exponentially stable compromise state. Using a structured modular network we further show that as conflict increases the local compromise branch terminates through a saddle-node fold rather than through a smooth mean-field symmetry-breaking transition. Modular polarized states persist on branches that are locally separated from the compromise branch. Direction-free dissipation does not shift the static structural threshold, but it delays escape from the saddle-node ghost and pushes the observable onset of polarization to larger conflicts. Our work identifies a dissipation-mediated mechanism, complementary to connectivity-based accounts, through which uninformed participants stabilize collective behavior in biological and engineered swarms.