Potential Pitfalls in Visual Models of Tipping Points -- And How to Fix Them

2025-09-11T13:04:12Z

Visual models play a crucial role in both science and science communication. However, the distinction between mere analogies and mathematically sound graphical representations is not easy and can be misunderstood not only by laypeople but also within academic literature itself. Moreover, even when the graphical representation exactly corresponds to the mathematical model, its interpretation is often far from obvious. In this paper we discuss the potential landscape visualization commonly used for tipping points in the context of nonlinear dynamics and reveal potential pitfalls, in particular when distinguishing bifurcation induced tipping (B-tipping) from noise-induced tipping (N-tipping). We propose new visualization techniques for tipping dynamics, carefully distinguishing between B- and N-tipping as well as between single systems and ensembles of systems. Explicitly, we apply these visualizations both to molecular cell biology and to climate science in order to reveal the crucial differences in the interpretation of the visual models. We find that it is crucial to explicitly discuss the assumptions made within the visual model and to be aware of the risk of misinterpretation. These findings apply to a wide range of readership, from graduate students - as some general knowledge of nonlinear systems is required - to research professionals working in the field of nonlinear sciences. This paper provides the theoretical groundwork for these new visualizations. As a next step, we propose to investigate the individual mental models that might be induced by these visualizations using empirical research that builds upon these findings.

Examining teaching assistant pedagogies in traditional laboratories and recitations

2025-09-11T04:15:30Z

Physics education research has consistently shown that students have higher learning outcomes when enrolled in active learning courses. However, while there is a lot of literature describing the difference between the two extremes of traditional vs. active learning courses, research has also shown that many classrooms actually lie on a spectrum rather than firmly falling into one category or the other. Understanding the pedagogical landscape is important for curricular development and dissemination, as well as targeted professional development efforts. Replicating and expanding on a study done by West et al., we observe graduate student Teaching Assistants (TAs) facilitating introductory physics labs and recitations using the Real-time Instructor Observing Tool (RIOT). We confirm West's finding of large variation between TAs' interactions during recitation sessions, but we also find that TAs facilitating traditional labs display fairly similar interaction profiles to each other. Additionally, we find that both the recitations and lab sessions we studied displayed very different interaction patterns from the CLASP ``Discussion/Labs'' studied by West et al. Specifically, we find that the amount of time instructors spend observing students is a key distinguishing characteristic between the traditional settings and the CLASP curriculum. We discuss the pedagogical features of each of the different learning environments as captured by RIOT. We share our results as a snapshot of the interactive elements of an introductory physics course at a four-year, public, master's granting institution situated in a discussion on implications for reform efforts.

Feedback That Clicks: Introductory Physics Students' Valued Features in AI Feedback Generated From Self-Crafted and Engineered Prompts

2025-09-10T11:47:27Z

Since the advent of GPT-3.5 in 2022, Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) has shown tremendous potential in STEM education, particularly in providing real-time, customized feedback to students in large-enrollment courses. A crucial skill that mediates effective use of AI is the systematic structuring of natural language instructions to AI models, commonly referred to as prompt engineering. This study has three objectives: (i) to investigate the sophistication of student-generated prompts when seeking feedback from AI on their arguments, (ii) to examine the features that students value in AI-generated feedback, and (iii) to analyze trends in student preferences for feedback generated from self-crafted prompts versus prompts incorporating prompt engineering techniques and principles of effective feedback. Results indicate that student-generated prompts typically reflect only a subset of foundational prompt engineering techniques. Despite this lack of sophistication, such as incomplete descriptions of task context, AI responses demonstrated contextual intuitiveness by accurately inferring context from the overall content of the prompt. We also identified 12 distinct features that students attribute the usefulness of AI-generated feedback, spanning four broader themes: Evaluation, Content, Presentation, and Depth. Finally, results show that students overwhelmingly prefer feedback generated from structured prompts, particularly those combining prompt engineering techniques with principles of effective feedback. Implications of these results such as integrating the principles of effective feedback in design and delivery of feedback through AI systems, and incorporating prompt engineering in introductory physics courses are discussed.

Making the quantum world accessible to young learners through Quantum Picturalism: An experimental study

2025-09-10T11:33:44Z

The educational value of a fully diagrammatic approach in a scientific field has never been explored. We present Quantum Picturalism (QPic), an entirely diagrammatic formalism for all of qubit quantum mechanics. This framework is particularly advantageous for young learners as a novel way to teach key concepts such as entanglement, measurement, and mixed-state quantum mechanics in a math-intensive subject. This eliminates traditional obstacles without compromising mathematical correctness - removing the need for matrices, vectors, tensors, complex numbers, and trigonometry as prerequisites to learning. Its significance lies in that a field as complex as Quantum Information Science and Technology (QIST), for which educational opportunities are typically exclusive to the university level and higher, can be introduced at high school level. In this study, we tested this hypothesis, examining whether QPic reduces cognitive load by lowering complex mathematical barriers while enhancing mental computation and conceptual understanding. The data was collected from an experiment conducted in 2023, whereby 54 high school students (aged 16-18) underwent 16 hours of training spread over eight weeks. The post-assessments illustrated promising outcomes in all three specific areas of focus: (1) whether QPic can alleviate technical barriers in learning QIST, (2) ensures that the content and teaching method are age appropriate, (3) increases confidence and motivation in science and STEM fields. There was a notable success rate in terms of teaching outcomes, with 82% of participants successfully passing an end-of-training exam and 48% achieving a distinction, indicating a high level of performance. The unique testing and training regime effectively reduced the technical barriers typically associated with traditional approaches, as hypothesized.

Utilizando o captador de guitarra como sensor: Construindo um kit para abordar a Lei de Faraday em sala de aula

2025-09-08T18:30:35Z

The approach to the concept of electromagnetic induction in physics education can present challenges, particularly regarding its distance from students' everyday experiences. The functioning of an electric guitar pickup can serve as an interesting example to contextualize the topic, allowing students to understand the correlation between the variation in magnetic field flux and the induced electromotive force. This study aims to present a low-cost project to explore Faraday's Law of Induction through an experimental kit composed mainly of an electric guitar pickup, an electric motor with a speed controller, a Light Dependent Resistor (LDR) sensor, and permanent magnets.

Women in Physics in the United Kingdom: A Review of Recent Policy and Initiatives

2025-09-08T16:00:37Z

Across the United Kingdom, initiatives designed to increase the participation and outcomes for women in physics continue, working with children of various ages as well as with adults. Improvements have been achieved by a combination of these initiatives and an accompanying strengthening of policy, but significant gender imbalances remain.

A Compact Two-Dimensional Radiation Detector for Educational Applications

2025-09-08T01:56:01Z

Recent advances in low-cost, portable cosmic-ray detectors have broadened citizen-science engagement in particle physics studies. Imaging applications such as muography, however, remain largely inaccessible because existing detectors typically require tens to hundreds of sensors, making them costly and complex. This gap underscores the need for a compact imaging detector. In this study, we developed SAKURA, a palm-sized two-dimensional muon scintillation detector that uses only four silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) and can be built for less than 1,000 USD. Its spatial resolution was evaluated using a 5 GeV/c muon beam at CERN's T10 beamline in September 2024, yielding 13.4 mm along the x-axis and 7.48 mm along the y-axis. The entire study, including designing and testing the detector, and analysing data, was undertaken by high school students, demonstrating that SAKURA makes radiation imaging accessible and practical even for non-specialists with the help of some professional scientists.

Constructing a Photonic Implementation of Quantum Key Distribution

2025-09-07T17:05:51Z

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) stands as a revolutionary approach to secure communication, using the principles of quantum mechanics to establish unbreakable channels. Unlike traditional cryptography, which relies on the computational difficulty of mathematical problems, QKD utilizes the inherent properties of quantum states to achieve information-theoretic security. This means that the security of the key exchange is guaranteed by the laws of physics, making it theoretically unbreakable even by an adversary with unlimited computational power. Currently, one of the most viable ways to implement QKD for communication is via photonics, namely, using phase-preserving long-distance optical fibers. The objective of this project is to implement photonic QKD in a laboratory setting. This will help demonstrate the protocol's robustness and provide a feasible implementation for educational demonstrations.

Pengaruh Model Pembelajaran Generatif Berbantuan Media Mind Mapping terhadap Kompetensi Fisika Siswa Kelas XI MIA SMAN 1 Painan

2025-09-07T04:49:42Z

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of the generative teaching model assisted by mind mapping media in terms of the physics competencies of class XI Science students of Senior High School 1 Painan. This study is a quasi-experimental type. The population for the study was all class XI students of Senior High School 1 Painan. Purposive sampling technique was used for sampling. The research samples were Class A and Class B. The instrument used was an objective question sheet. The t-test was used to analyze the data, and the significance level was 0.05. The study showed a significant difference between classes that implemented the generative teaching model assisted by mind mapping media and classes that implemented the teaching model commonly used by teachers through the help of mind mapping media. The average student learning score for classes using the generative teaching model was 79.20, and the average student learning score for classes using the teaching model commonly used by educators was 76.15. The impact of the generative teaching model assisted by mind mapping media was seen in the results of the student learning process, which were analyzed and the hypothesis was tested. Based on the hypothesis test, the t table was 1.09 and the t count was 2.00. The condition for H0 to be rejected is if ttable lest than tcount. The t count value is in the rejection of H0. Because all variables are controlled, except for the learning process model, it can be achieved. The conclusion is that the application of the generative teaching model assisted by mind mapping media on the Dynamics of Motion material contributes a positive influence to student learning outcomes.

Teaching STEM Courses using Ignatian Pedagogy

2025-09-06T18:48:07Z

Despite the impact of the Jesuit educational endeavor on the rise of science, the Ignatian Pedagogical Paradigm (IPP), the signature Jesuit pedagogy, is not frequently used to teach courses in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM), and very little literature exists documenting any such attempts. In this paper, I describe a framework for how to apply the IPP to STEM courses using active-engagement strategies and assessment tools from disciplinary educational research (DBER). I provide three examples of how I have implemented the IPP in physics courses at various levels in the curriculum at a Jesuit University complete with assessment results that demonstrate student learning. I stress that beyond the technical, cyclical elements of the IPP, a truly Ignatian course needs to pay close attention to Jesuit charisms such as cura personalis, magis, and educating men and women with and for others.

Exploring Quantum Entanglement: A Hands-on Course on Spin Dynamics and Entanglement Transfer with Python Modules

2025-09-03T12:47:00Z

Quantum entanglement is a captivating phenomenon in quantum physics, characterized by intricate and non-classical correlations between particles. This phenomenon plays a crucial role in quantum computing and measurement processes. In this hands-on course students explore the dynamics of quantum systems with up to three spins, introducing the fundamental mechanisms by which entanglement evolves and transfers within such systems. Through detailed examples, simulations, and analyses, the hands-on course offers insights into the fundamental principles of entanglement. The provided \code{python} modules reproduce the presented results and serve as a basis for further projects. The target audience of this hands-on course is physics enthusiasts among students in their first semesters.

Blowing in a drinking straw: introducing quantum physics

2025-09-02T14:41:47Z

We present an educational approach aimed at introducing the fundamental concepts of quantum mechanics (QM). By exploiting the formal analogy between sound wave behavior in an acoustic pipe (a drinking straw) and the quantum infinite square potential well, we provide an intuitive framework that explains the origin of energy quantization in bound quantum systems (such as atoms), introduces the concept of wave function (WF), and lays the groundwork for discussing the Heisenberg uncertainty relations. The proposed method enables low-cost experimental activities that actively involve students, facilitating a meaningful connection between theoretical principles and empirical observations. Moreover, it encourages critical reflection on the Copenhagen interpretation of the WF, promoting a deeper conceptual understanding.

Enhancing Science Literacy through Cognitive Conflict-Based Generative Learning Model: An Experimental Study in Physics Learning

2025-09-01T09:31:35Z

This experimental study investigates the effectiveness of the Cognitive Conflict-Based Generative Learning Model (GLBCC) in enhancing science literacy among high school physics students. The novelty of this research lies in the innovative integration of cognitive conflict strategies with generative learning principles through a six stage structured framework, specifically designed to address persistent misconceptions in physics education while systematically developing scientific literacy competencies. The research employed pretest-posttest control group design involving 167 Grade XI students from three schools. Students were randomly assigned to experimental groups (n = 83) that received GLBCC instruction and control groups (n = 84) that used the expository learning model. Science literacy was measured using validated instruments assessing scientific knowledge, inquiry processes, and application skills across six key indicators. Statistical analysis using ANOVA with Tukey HSD post-hoc tests revealed significant improvements in science literacy scores for students receiving GLBCC instruction compared to traditional methods (p < 0.001). This study makes a unique contribution to physics education by demonstrating how the deliberate creation of cognitive conflict, combined with authentic real-world physics phenomena, can effectively restructure students conceptual understanding and enhance their scientific thinking capabilities. Factor analysis identified four critical implementation factors: science literacy development components, learning stages and orientation, and objectives, and knowledge construction processes. The findings provide empirical evidence supporting the integration of cognitive conflict strategies with generative learning approaches in physics education, offering practical implications

Investigation of the Inter-Rater Reliability between Large Language Models and Human Raters in Qualitative Analysis

2025-08-31T00:33:38Z

Qualitative analysis is typically limited to small datasets because it is time-intensive. Moreover, a second human rater is required to ensure reliable findings. Artificial intelligence tools may replace human raters if we demonstrate high reliability compared to human ratings. We investigated the inter-rater reliability of state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs), ChatGPT-4o and ChatGPT-4.5-preview, in rating audio transcripts coded manually. We explored prompts and hyperparameters to optimize model performance. The participants were 14 undergraduate student groups from a university in the midwestern United States who discussed problem-solving strategies for a project. We prompted an LLM to replicate manual coding, and calculated Cohen's Kappa for inter-rater reliability. After optimizing model hyperparameters and prompts, the results showed substantial agreement ($κ>0.6$) for three themes and moderate agreement on one. Our findings demonstrate the potential of GPT-4o and GPT-4.5 for efficient, scalable qualitative analysis in physics education and identify their limitations in rating domain-general constructs.

Quantum Computing Education in Latin America: Experiences and Strategies

2025-08-30T15:25:15Z

Quantum computing is a rapidly advancing field with the potential to drive scientific, educational, and technological development. However, it faces a significant shortage of qualified experts, creating an urgent demand for skilled professionals. In Latin America, quantum education remains in its early stages, further widening the regional talent and access gap due to limited educational infrastructure and financial constraints. This work presents an initiative to integrate quantum computing into higher education in Latin America through the application of the European Competence Framework for Quantum Technologies, which offers a standardized approach to defining competency requirements and assessing essential skills in the field. We propose introductory courses aligned with the frameworks guidelines, designed to meet industry standards and reach a broad audience. Additionally, we introduce supplementary resources, including team dynamics and evaluation methodologies, to enhance the educational ecosystem. These initiatives aim to create a sustainable and comprehensive quantum education model across Latin America, to close the regional skills gap, foster inclusivity, and prepare a diverse workforce to contribute innovative solutions on the global stage.