In between myth and reality: AI for math -- a case study in category theory

2025-04-17T21:58:30Z

Recently, there is an increasing interest in understanding the performance of AI systems in solving math problems. A multitude of tests have been performed, with mixed conclusions. In this paper we discuss an experiment we have made in the direction of mathematical research, with two of the most prominent contemporary AI systems. One of the objective of this experiment is to get an understanding of how AI systems can assist mathematical research. Another objective is to support the AI systems developers by formulating suggestions for directions of improvement.

Adding the constant evasion and constant prediction numbers to Cichoń's maximum

2025-04-17T18:19:52Z

Let $\mathfrak{e}^\mathsf{const}_2$ be the constant evasion number, that is, the size of the least family $F\subseteq{}^{\omega}2$ of reals such that for each predictor $\pi\colon {}^{<\omega}2\to 2$ there is $x\in F$ which is not constantly predicted by $\pi$; and let $\mathfrak{v}_2^\mathsf{const}$ be the constant prediction number, that is, the size of the least family $\Pi_2$ of functions $\pi\colon {}^{<\omega}2\to 2$ such that for each $x\in{}^{\omega}2$ there is $\pi\in\Pi_2$ that predicts constantly $x$. In this work, we show that the constant evasion number $\mathfrak{e}_2^{\mathrm{cons}}$ and the constant prediction number $\mathfrak{v}_2^\mathsf{const}$ can be added to Cicho\'n's maximum with distinct values.

Negative resolution to the $C^*$-algebraic Tarski problem

2025-04-17T17:47:21Z

We compute the $K_1$-group of ultraproducts of unital, simple $C^*$-algebras with unique trace and strict comparison. As an application, we prove that the reduced free group $C^*$-algebras $C^*_r(F_m)$ and $C^*_r(F_n)$ are elementarily equivalent (i.e., have isomorphic ultrapowers) if and only if $m = n$. This settles in the negative the $C^*$-algebraic analogue of Tarski's 1945 problem for groups.

Strict comparison in reduced group $C^*$-algebras

2025-04-17T17:41:14Z

We prove that for every $n\geq 2$, the reduced group $C^*$-algebras of the countable free groups $C^*_r(\mathbb{F}_n)$ have strict comparison. Our method works in a general setting: for $G$ in a large family of non-amenable groups, including hyperbolic groups, free products, mapping class groups, right-angled Artin groups etc., we have $C^*_r(G)$ have strict comparison. This work also has several applications in the theory of $C^*$-algebras including: resolving Leonel Robert's selflessness problem for $C^*_r(G)$; uniqueness of embeddings of the Jiang-Su algebra $\mathcal{Z}$ up to approximate unitary equivalence into $C^*_r(G)$; full computations of the Cuntz semigroup of $C^*_r(G)$ and future directions in the $C^*$-classification program.

The weakness of finding descending sequences in ill-founded linear orders

2025-04-17T13:57:31Z

We explore the Weihrauch degree of the problems ``find a bad sequence in a non-well quasi order'' ($\mathsf{BS}$) and ``find a descending sequence in an ill-founded linear order'' ($\mathsf{DS}$). We prove that $\mathsf{DS}$ is strictly Weihrauch reducible to $\mathsf{BS}$, correcting our mistaken claim in [arXiv:2010.03840]. This is done by separating their respective first-order parts. On the other hand, we show that $\mathsf{BS}$ and $\mathsf{DS}$ have the same finitary and deterministic parts, confirming that $\mathsf{BS}$ and $\mathsf{DS}$ have very similar uniform computational strength. We prove that K\"onig's lemma $\mathsf{KL}$ and the problem $\mathsf{wList}_{2^{\mathbb{N}},\leq\omega}$ of enumerating a given non-empty countable closed subset of $2^{\mathbb{N}}$ are not Weihrauch reducible to $\mathsf{DS}$ or $\mathsf{BS}$, resolving two main open questions raised in [arXiv:2010.03840]. We also answer the question, raised in [arXiv:1804.10968], on the existence of a ``parallel quotient'' operator, and study the behavior of $\mathsf{BS}$ and $\mathsf{DS}$ under the quotient with some known problems.

On the asymptotic behaviour of stochastic processes, with applications to supermartingale convergence, Dvoretzky's approximation theorem, and stochastic quasi-Fejér monotonicity

2025-04-17T13:11:26Z

We prove a novel and general result on the asymptotic behavior of stochastic processes which conform to a certain relaxed supermartingale condition. Our result provides quantitative information in the form of an explicit and effective construction of a rate of convergence for this process, both in mean and almost surely, that is moreover highly uniform in the sense that it only depends on very few data of the surrounding objects involved in the iteration. We then apply this result to derive new quantitative versions of well-known concepts and theorems from stochastic approximation, in particular providing effective rates for a variant of the Robbins-Siegmund theorem, Dvoretzky's convergence theorem, as well as the convergence of stochastic quasi-Fej\'er monotone sequences, the latter of which formulated in a novel and highly general metric context. We utilize the classic and widely studied Robbins-Monro procedure as a template to evaluate our quantitative results and their applicability in greater detail. We conclude by illustrating the breadth of potential further applications with a brief discussion on a variety of other well-known iterative procedures from stochastic approximation, covering a range of different applied scenarios to which our methods can be immediately applied. Throughout, we isolate and discuss special cases of our results which even allow for the construction of fast, and in particular linear, rates.

A note on one-variable theorems for NSOP

2025-04-17T08:38:02Z

We give an example of an SOP theory $T$, such that any $L(M)$-formula $\varphi(x,y)$ with $|y|=1$ is NSOP. We show that any such $T$ must have the independence property. We also give a simplified proof of Lachlan's theorem that if every $L$-formula $\varphi(x,y)$ with $|x|=1$ is NSOP, then $T$ is NSOP.

A note on dual Dedekind finiteness

2025-04-17T03:09:37Z

A set $A$ is dually Dedekind finite if every surjection from $A$ onto $A$ is injective; otherwise, $A$ is dually Dedekind infinite. It is proved consistent with $\mathsf{ZF}$ (i.e., the Zermelo--Fraenkel set theory without the axiom of choice) that there exists a family $\langle A_n\rangle_{n\in\omega}$ of sets such that, for all $n\in\omega$, $A_n^n$ is dually Dedekind finite whereas $A_n^{n+1}$ is dually Dedekind infinite. This resolves a question that was left open in [J. Truss, Fund. Math. 84, 187--208 (1974)].

Mazurkiewicz Sets and Containment of Sierpiński-Zygmund Functions under Rotations

2025-04-17T03:04:18Z

A Mazurkiewicz set is a plane subset that intersect every straight line at exactly two points, and a Sierpi\'{n}ski-Zygmund function is a function from $\mathbb{R}$ into $\mathbb{R}$ that has as little of the standard continuity as possible. Building on the recent work of Kharazishvili, we construct a Mazurkiewicz set that contains a Sierpi\'{n}ski-Zygmund function in every direction and another one that contains none in any direction. Furthermore, we show that whether a Mazurkiewicz set can be expressed as a union of two Sierpi\'{n}ski-Zygmund functions is independent of Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory with the Axiom of Choice (ZFC). Some open problems related to the containment of Hamel functions are stated.

Boolean-valued second-order logic revisited

2025-04-17T02:56:54Z

Following the paper~[3] by V\"{a}\"{a}n\"{a}nen and the author, we continue to investigate on the difference between Boolean-valued second-order logic and full second-order logic. We show that the compactness number of Boolean-valued second-order logic is equal to $\omega_1$ if there are proper class many Woodin cardinals. This contrasts the result by Magidor~[10] that the compactness number of full second-order logic is the least extendible cardinal. We also introduce the inner model $C^{2b}$ constructed from Boolean-valued second-order logic using the construction of G\"{o}del's Constructible Universe L. We show that $C^{2b}$ is the least inner model of $\mathsf{ZFC}$ closed under $\mathrm{M}_n^{\#}$ operators for all $n < \omega$, and that $C^{2b}$ enjoys various nice properties as G\"{o}del's L does, assuming that Projective Determinacy holds in any set generic extension. This contrasts the result by Myhill and Scott~[14] that the inner model constructed from full second-order logic is equal to HOD, the class of all hereditarily ordinal definable sets.

Effective Completeness for S4.3.1-Theories with Respect to Discrete Linear Models

2025-04-16T19:16:34Z

The computable model theory of modal logic was initiated by Suman Ganguli and Anil Nerode in [4]. They use an effective Henkin-type construction to effectivize various completeness theorems from classical modal logic. This construction has the feature of only producing models whose frames can be obtained by adding edges to a tree digraph. Consequently, this construction cannot prove an effective version of a well-known completeness theorem which states that every $\mathsf{S4.3.1}$-theory has a model whose accessibility relation is a linear order of order type $\omega$. We prove an effectivization of that theorem by means of a new construction adapted from that of Ganguli and Nerode.

On a cofinal Reinhardt embedding without Powerset

2025-04-16T15:41:23Z

In this paper, we provide a positive answer to a question by Matthews whether $\mathsf{ZF}^-$ is consistent with a non-trivial cofinal Reinhardt elementary embedding $j\colon V\to V$. The consistency follows from $\mathsf{ZFC} + I_0$, and more precisely, Schultzenberg's model of $\mathsf{ZF}$ with an elementary embedding $k\colon V_{\lambda+2}\to V_{\lambda+2}$.

Variants of Solovay reducibility

2025-04-16T14:51:57Z

Outside of the left-c.e. reals, Solovay reducibility is considered to be behaved badly [10.1007/978-0-387-68441-3]. Proposals for variants of Solovay reducibility that are better suited for the investigation of arbitrary, not necessarily left-c.e. reals were made by Rettinger and Zheng [10.1007/978-3-540-27798-9_39], and, recently, by Titov [10.11588/heidok.00034250] and by Kumabe and co-authors [10.4115/jla.2020.12.2; 10.3233/COM-230486]. These variants all coincide with the original version of Solovay reducibility on the left-c.e. reals. Furthermore, they are all defined in terms of translation functions. The latter translate between computable approximations in the case of Rettinger and Zheng, are monotone in the case of Titov, and are functions between reals in the case of Kumabe et al. In what follows, we derive new results on the mentioned variants and their relation to each other. In particular, we obtain that Solovay reducibility defined in terms of translation function on rationals implies Solovay reducibility defined in terms of translation functions on reals, and we show that the original version of Solovay reducibility is strictly weaker than its monotone variant. Solovay reducibility and its variants mentioned so far have tight connections to Martin-L\"of randomness, the strongest and most central notion of a random sequence. For the investigation of Schnorr randomness, total variants of Solovay reducibility have been introduced by Merkle and Titov [10.48550/arXiv.2407.14869] in 2022 and, independently, by Kumabe et al. [10.3233/COM-230486] in 2024, the latter again via real-valued translation functions. In what follows, we show that total Solovay reducibility defined in terms of rational functions implies total Solovay reducibility defined in terms of real functions.

Algorithmic correspondence and analytic rules

2025-04-15T14:19:50Z

We introduce the algorithm MASSA which takes classical modal formulas in input, and, when successful, effectively generates: (a) (analytic) geometric rules of the labelled calculus G3K, and (b) cut-free derivations (of a certain `canonical' shape) of each given input formula in the geometric labelled calculus obtained by adding the rule in output to G3K. We show that MASSA successfully terminates whenever its input formula is a (definite) analytic inductive formula, in which case, the geometric axiom corresponding to the output rule is, modulo logical equivalence, the first-order correspondent of the input formula. In proving the correctness of MASSA, we also show that the algorithm for the elimination of second-order quantifiers SCAN is complete with respect to the class of inductive analytic formulas. Finally, we show how our algorithm can be extended to the class of inductive formulas and to modal logic with quantifiers.

A computable version of Hall's Harem Theorem and Geometric von Neumann Conjecture

2025-04-15T12:39:44Z

We prove a version of Hall's Harem Theorem where the matching realizes a function with some special properties of its cycles. Using this approach we also prove a new computable version of Hall's Harem theorem. We apply it to non-amenable computable coarse spaces.